Apple Ordered To Pay $625m In Patent Lawsuit: Time For A U.S. Patent Reform!?


Fresh and interesting article posted on WIPR about the East Texas Federal District Court jury verdict that ordered Apple to pay $626 million to (patent troll) VirnetX for willfully infringing patents with FaceTime, iMessage, and VPN services. Time for a U.S. patent reform!?

Happy reading!

"A Texas court has ruled that Apple infringed four patents owned by licensing company VirnetX and has ordered the technology company to pay $625 million in damages.
Yesterday, February 3, a jury at the US District Court for the Eastern District of Texas ruled that Apple’s FaceTime, iMessage and VPN On Demand services infringed the patents.
All four patents cover an online secure communication network.
According to the final order, VirnetX proved through a “preponderance of evidence” that Apple was liable for infringement.
In total, the court awarded VirnetX $625.6 million in damages.
Jason Cassady, principal at Caldwell, Cassady & Curry and representing VirnetX, said: “We are thankful for the jurors’ hard work and attention in this case, and for reaching a just verdict. The jury saw what we have been saying all along: Apple has been infringing VirnetX’s patented technology.”
But the story may not end here.
Yesterday, February 3, Apple filed a motion requesting a new jury trial after it claimed VirnetX’s counsel made arguments that were intended to “confuse, mislead and inflame” the jury to “render a verdict not based on the record”.
“VirnetX’s closing was replete with misrepresentations of the record, assertions about the credibility of witnesses not grounded in the record, and similar misstatements,” Apple said.
Apple added that the licensing company’s lawyers' closing argument was “outside the record and inconsistent with the law”."

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Ethical Coffee Company Sues Nestlé Nespresso For €150m

Image
Fresh and interesting article posted by WIPR  concerning a European patent for a "device for preparing a drink extracted from a capsule", owned by Ethical Coffee Company (ECC). As you all know, Nespresso machines brew espresso from coffee capsules, a type of pre-apportioned single-use container of ground coffee and flavorings. In the case at hand, ECC, a Swiss Company, also creating capsules compatible with Nespresso machines, is suing Nestlé, in Paris, for alleged patent infringement. In other words, ECC is not happy with the way Nestlé modified the Nespresso machines back in 2010, keeping competitors’ capsules out of them and, more importantly, violating the patented "harpoon mechanism". Happy reading! "The man who oversaw  Nestlé’s Nespresso brand of coffee machines  has sued his former employer for alleged patent infringement.   Ethical Coffee Company , which makes coffee capsules that can be used in the Nespresso machine, has claimed that
Read more

A Look Inside The Apple Watch : Intellectual Property Rights And Future Legal Battles

Image
It is not just a watch. It is a masterpiece of intellectual property (IP) rights. It is not just a revolutionary product. It is the next chapter in Apple Inc.’s story. Apple believes in technology designed for the wrist (such as a smartwatch), but also in a strong design patent protection strategy. To protect this wearable, as a result of their investment, Apple applied for and received several design patents. Every detail is protected: the drawer where the watches are shown, the bracelet, the “slide-in” interchangeable strap system mechanism, the digital crown, the display, the charger, the retail box, etc. Future innovations will however continue to copy this kind of consumer products and challenge the Courts. In this context, developing and/or acquiring intellectual property rights may create a solid foundation for growth and success. Indeed, a winning exploitation of IP assets, including but not limited to know-how, patents, trademarks, aligned with your passion for innovati
Read more

Jouets connectés : Méfiez-vous des poupées et robots qui violent la vie privée de vos enfants... et la vôtre !

Image
C ’est la période des fêtes : le moment est venu de trouver le prochain cadeau de vos enfants ! Les Playmobil et Lego étant un peu trop muets à votre goût, vous penchez cette année pour les jouets dits « connectés », tels la poupée « My Friend Cayla » et le robot « I-QUE ». Méfiez-vous, bien qu’innovants, ces jouets ne respectent pas toujours la vie privée de vos enfants ! Il n’en fallait bien pas moins à la CNIL pour mettre la main dessus… Source Qu’est-ce qu’un objet connecté ? Les objets connectés sont des objets dotés de moyen de communication avec ou sans fil (Wi-Fi, Bluetooth) qui prennent souvent la forme d’objets d’apparence anodine (poupées, robots, etc.) et qui collectent des informations. On les retrouve dans de nombreux domaines, comme la domotique, le sport, le bien-être et la santé, les activités de loisirs, etc. Ces objets peuvent être autonomes ou peuvent fonctionner avec un smartphone ou une tablette. Ce dernier sert de télécommande pour les contrôler
Read more